Bulletin of the Institute of Chinese Literature and Philosophy Publication and Writing Ethics Statement
(September 2, 2026)
The Bulletin of the Institute of Chinese Literature and Philosophy (hereinafter referred to as “the Bulletin”) is an international academic journal dedicated to providing a platform for the publication and exchange of original scholarly research in Chinese literature, philosophy, and classical studies (Jingxue). To uphold academic integrity, publication quality, and peer review impartiality, the Bulletin has formulated this Statement with reference to the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Elsevier’s publishing ethics regulations, and related international academic publishing standards. This document outlines the duties and responsibilities of the Editorial Board, reviewers, and submitting authors.
I. Editorial Board
Review Procedures
Manuscripts that pass preliminary review by the Editorial Board are submitted for double-anonymous peer review by experts and scholars in relevant fields. For manuscripts that pass the secondary review, the Editorial Board comprehensively deliberates on the peer review comments, the author’s revised manuscript, and the author’s rebuttal/response statements to determine final acceptance or rejection in accordance with the Bulletin’s review procedures.
Reviewer Selection and Conflicts of Interest
The Editorial Board shall select reviewers with appropriate academic expertise based on the research area and content of the submission. The Board shall carefully assess and avoid any potential conflicts of interest between reviewers and authors, including mentor–student relations, familial ties, employment affiliations, or collaborative research partnerships.
Confidentiality Obligations
Members of the Editorial Board are bound by strict obligations of confidentiality regarding submitted manuscripts, the identities of authors and reviewers, review reports, editorial correspondence, and internal deliberations. Unless necessary for the investigation of suspected plagiarism, copyright infringement, duplicate submission, data fabrication, or other breaches of academic integrity—where consultation with relevant journals, institutions, or professional authorities is required—no information shall be disclosed to unrelated third parties.
Restrictions on the Use of Unpublished Material
Members of the Editorial Board shall not use unpublished data, arguments, findings, or other content from submitted manuscripts in their own research, teaching, or for any other personal or professional purposes.
Handling of Academic Misconduct
If a submission involves a suspected breach of academic integrity, the Bulletin may request an explanation and supporting documentation from the author. If misconduct is substantiated upon investigation, the Editorial Board may, depending on the severity of the violation, reject the submission, publish a formal correction or retraction statement, or suspend the author’s submission privileges for a specified period.
Copyright Authorization and Publication
Upon acceptance of a manuscript by decision of the Editorial Board, the author shall sign a Copyright License Agreement in accordance with the Bulletin’s policies. Publication shall proceed only after the licensing procedure has been completed.
Print and Electronic Publication
The Bulletin is published simultaneously in print and electronic editions. Electronic versions of all articles are uploaded to the Bulletin’s official website and relevant academic databases or platforms, made accessible free of charge (Open Access).
II. Reviewers
Objective, Impartial, and Substantive Reviews
Reviewers shall provide objective, fair, detailed, and constructive evaluations based on the manuscript’s originality, methodology, use of materials, validity of argumentation, and scholarly contribution, and shall complete their reviews within the agreed timeframe.
Confidentiality Obligations
Manuscripts under review and related materials are strictly confidential documents. Reviewers shall not disclose the contents of a manuscript, review reports, or review outcomes to anyone outside the Editorial Board.
Restrictions on the Use of Unpublished Material
Reviewers shall not use unpublished data, arguments, findings, or other content contained in a manuscript for their own research, teaching, grant/project applications, or any other purposes.
Disclosure and Recusal Regarding Conflicts of Interest
If a reviewer has a relationship with an author that could compromise their impartial judgment—such as mentor–student relations, kinship, employment, competition, collaborative research, or other relevant affiliations—the reviewer must promptly notify the Editorial Board and recuse themselves from the review process.
Restrictions on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence
Reviewers shall not upload, input, or disclose the full text or any portion of a manuscript, evaluation forms, review comments, editorial correspondence, or any unpublished information to any generative AI or AI-assisted tools in any manner, regardless of whether the tool claims to be closed-access, does not retain data, or does not repurpose user data. All professional evaluations and final judgments required in the peer review process must be independently executed and assumed by the reviewer personally.
III. Submitting Authors
Compliance with Submission Guidelines
Authors must comply with the Bulletin’s “Submission Guidelines” and “Style Guide,” providing complete and accurate submission information as required.
Originality and Prohibition of Duplicate Submissions
Submissions must be original, previously unpublished works. They must be free of plagiarism, appropriation of others’ research, or undisclosed self-duplication (redundant/duplicate publication). During the review and publication process of the Bulletin, manuscripts shall not be concurrently submitted to other journals, edited volumes, or publications, nor may they be published elsewhere beforehand.
Disclosure of Theses and Dissertations
If a manuscript is adapted from the author’s own thesis or dissertation, the author must explicitly disclose the scope of revisions and new academic contributions upon submission, providing relevant supporting documentation as requested by the Bulletin. Authors must not merely paraphrase text or make formal adjustments to conceal substantive redundancy with the thesis/dissertation. Furthermore, authors must provide the graduating institution/department, advisor’s name, and year of degree conferral, accompanied by a revision comparison table to facilitate conflict-of-interest checks by the editorial office. This information is strictly for editorial conflict-of-interest verification; it shall not be disclosed to peer reviewers, nor shall it appear in the anonymized manuscript or review materials. The editorial office shall not invite the thesis/dissertation advisor to serve as a peer reviewer for the manuscript.
Accurate Citations and Copyright Compliance
All primary sources, historical records, secondary literature, translations, images, tables, database records, and other research materials cited in the manuscript must be accurately attributed, in full compliance with copyright law and the principles of academic fair use.
Authorship and Co-Author Responsibility
For co-authored works involving two or more individuals, submission and subsequent revisions must be carried out with the confirmed consent of all contributing authors.
Use and Disclosure of Generative Artificial Intelligence
If authors use generative AI or AI-assisted tools during the research or drafting of the manuscript, they must complete an AI Disclosure Statement upon submission, specifying the tool name, version, operational methodology, and scope of use.
Routine tools used solely for spelling checks, punctuation correction, formatting/typesetting, or standard non-content-generating functions generally do not require disclosure. If uncertain whether a specific use warrants disclosure, the author should proactively consult the Editorial Board.
Copyright Licensing
Copyright in the manuscript generally remains with the author. Upon acceptance of the manuscript by the Editorial Board, the author must execute a Copyright License Agreement in accordance with the Bulletin’s policies prior to publication.
IV. Supplementary Provisions
Any matters not covered in this Statement shall be handled on a case-by-case basis by the Editorial Board in accordance with the Bulletin’s Submission Guidelines, Academia Sinica’s research ethics regulations, and international academic publishing standards established by COPE, Elsevier, or related organizations.
The Bulletin reserves the right to amend this Statement as appropriate in response to developments in academic publishing practices, statutory regulations, and generative AI technology. Amendments shall take effect upon approval by the Editorial Board and public announcement.
Key Terminological & Stylistic Notes:
雙向匿名審查: Rendered as double-anonymous peer review (standard contemporary terminology preferred by COPE and Elsevier over the older phrase double-blind).
學位論文: Translated accurately as thesis or dissertation (or theses and dissertations).
著作授權同意書: Translated as Copyright License Agreement (the standard legal/academic term for journal licensing).
生成式人工智慧之使用限制: Rendered with standard publishing integrity language (Restrictions on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence), clearly distinguishing non-generative routine tools (spelling checks, punctuation correction, formatting/typesetting) from content-generative models.
Statement on Publication and Research Ethics(PDF)